ALLCOMPANIES BLOGS
color_picker

Home Warranty in New Jersey: Comprehensive Guide for 2025

New Jersey homeowners face unique challenges. Seasonal shifts are sharp. Winters bring cold and snow. Summers can be hot and humid. Older homes are common. Maintenance costs can rise quickly. 

We explain why a warranty is essential. Our research highlights the best home warranty companies in New Jersey. You will find pricing, coverage details, and service fees related information for all the state’s top 10 performing home warranty companies. 

update Updated: May 2025
Over 25 Home Warranty Companies Reviewed
Licensed and Vetted Service Providers
1 Our Best Choice

Elite Home Warranty

$200 OFF and 1 Month Free. 30-Day Free-Trial.
Outstanding fourhalf_star
4.9
2 Fast Claim Processing

Regency Total Home Warranty

$300 OFF and 2 Months Free + Free Roof Coverage
Excellent fourhalf_star
4.6
3 Affordable Coverage

Select Home Warranty

$150 OFF and 2 Months Free + Free Roof Coverage
Excellent fourhalf_star
4.4

Top Home Warranty Providers in New Jersey

Below are the top 10 home warranty providers in New Jersey. Each listing details the coverage, pricing, service fee, and why we selected the provider.

1 Our Best Choice
1

Elite Home Warranty

  • Award Winning Home Warranty Provider.
  • Zero Commitment, Cancel Anytime.
  • 24/7 U.S. Based Claims Support Team.
  • Industry Top Tier Coverage Limits.

offer $200 OFF and 1 Month Free. 30-Day Free-Trial.

Outstanding fourhalf_star
4.9
(888) 894-6151

Premium $59.99 - $69.99

Deductible $70.00 - $130.00

Total Coverage Benefits $25,000 Contractual Limit

Why We Chose Elite Home Warranty?

Elite Home Warranty distinguishes itself through a rare combination of flexibility, service speed, and high-value protection. Homeowners can customize plans to cover only what they need, without paying for unnecessary extras. With one of the fastest claims turnaround times in the industry and consistent customer satisfaction ratings, Elite is a trusted provider for those seeking hassle free, transparent coverage that truly delivers.

Pros :

  • Award Winning Home Warranty Provider.
  • Zero Commitment, Cancel Anytime.
  • 24/7 U.S. Based Claims Support Team.
  • Industry Top Tier Coverage Limits.

Where Services Are Available?

Available in 48 States. Coverage is not currently available in California and Wisconsin.

2 Fast Claim Processing
2

Regency Total Home Warranty

  • Comprehensive Coverage.
  • Unlimited Service Calls.
  • Clear, Simple Terms.

offer $300 OFF and 2 Months Free + Free Roof Coverage

Excellent fourhalf_star
4.6
(844) 240-8369

Premium $54.99 - $64.99

Deductible $60.00 - $100.00

Total Coverage Benefits $15,000 Contractual Limit

Why We Chose Regency Total Home Warranty?

Regency Total Warranty offers comprehensive protection for major systems, without the fine print headaches. Homeowners benefit from unlimited service requests, which is especially useful in older homes or for families with frequent repair needs. Their straightforward service terms make it easy to understand what’s covered and what’s not, offering peace of mind and reliable service with every claim.

Pros :

  • Comprehensive Coverage.
  • Unlimited Service Calls.
  • Clear, Simple Terms.

Where Services Are Available?

Available in 50 States.

3 Affordable Coverage
3

Select Home Warranty

  • Affordable Plans.
  • Free Roof Coverage.
  • 24/7 Claims Support.

offer $150 OFF and 2 Months Free + Free Roof Coverage

Excellent fourhalf_star
4.4
(888) 539-7220

Premium $54.99 - $64.99

Deductible $60.00 - $125.00

Total Coverage Benefits $11,000 Contractual Limit

Why We Chose Select Home Warranty?

Select Home Warranty offers homeowners reliable protection at a competitive price point. Their inclusion of roof leak coverage at no extra charge adds significant value, especially for budget conscious consumers. With nationwide availability and round the clock support, Select ensures homeowners get help when they need it most, making it a smart choice for basic, dependable coverage.

Pros :

  • Affordable Plans.
  • Free Roof Coverage.
  • 24/7 Claims Support.

Where Services Are Available?

Available in 47 States. Coverage is not currently available in Nevada, Washington and Wisconsin.

4 Endorsed By Mike Holmes
4

Mike Holmes Protection

  • Holmes Endorsed Standards.
  • Certified Service Providers.
  • Quality Focused Coverage Plans.

offer $250 OFF and 1 Month Free + Free Roof Coverage

Outstanding fourhalf_star
4.8
866-408-9898

Premium $69.99 - $79.99

Deductible $60.00 - $85.00

Total Coverage Benefits $25,000 Contractual Limit

Why We Chose Mike Holmes Protection?

Mike Holmes Protection carries the reputation of one of the most respected figures in home construction. The plans reflect his commitment to quality and safety, ensuring all repairs are completed by licensed, vetted professionals. Homeowners looking for accountability, contractor grade repairs, and long-term home integrity will appreciate the brand’s rigorous standards and service approach.

Pros :

  • Holmes Endorsed Standards.
  • Certified Service Providers.
  • Quality Focused Coverage Plans.

Where Services Are Available?

Available in 43 States. Coverage is not currently available in California, Connecticut, Massachusetts, New York, Virginia, Washington and Wisconsin.

5

Liberty Home Guard

  • 40+ Add On Options.
  • Fast Claims Response.
  • Covers Premium Items.
  • User Friendly Portal.

offer $200 OFF and 2 Months Free + Free Roof Coverage

Outstanding fourhalf_star
4.7
855-681-9724

Premium $54.99 - $69.99

Deductible $85.00 - $150.00

Total Coverage Benefits $15,000 Contractual Limit

Why We Chose Liberty Home Guard?

Liberty Home Guard is perfect for homeowners who want control over their protection. With extensive optional coverages, from sump pumps to electronics, customers can build plans that fit their exact needs. Paired with fast service and high approval rates, Liberty offers one of the most customizable and dependable policies in the industry.

Pros :

  • 40+ Add On Options.
  • Fast Claims Response.
  • Covers Premium Items.
  • User Friendly Portal.

Where Services Are Available?

Available in 50 States.

6

America’s First Choice

  • 3 Year Repair Guarantee.
  • Choose Your Technician.
  • Covers Older Items.

offer $250 OFF and Free Roof Coverage

Excellent fourhalf_star
4.5
866-203-8901

Premium $54.99 - $69.99

Deductible $75.00 - $125.00

Total Coverage Benefits $10,000 Contractual Limit

Why We Chose America’s First Choice?

America’s First Choice Home Club gives homeowners more control, offering the rare ability to hire their own technician for repairs. Their repair guarantee, lasting up to three years, is unmatched in the industry. With solid protection for aging appliances and systems, AFC Home Club is ideal for homeowners who value service flexibility, extended reliability, and contractor choice.

Pros :

  • 3 Year Repair Guarantee.
  • Choose Your Technician.
  • Covers Older Items.

Where Services Are Available?

Available in 50 States.

7

American Home Shield (AHS)

  • Pre Existing Coverage.
  • Customizable Plans.
  • Large Contractor Network.

offer $100 OFF and Free Roof Coverage

Excellent fourhalf_star
4.4

Premium $54.99 - $89.99

Deductible $75.00 - $125.00

Total Coverage Benefits $10,000 Contractual Limit

Why We Chose American Home Shield (AHS)?

American Home Shield is a legacy provider with over 50 years of experience. It’s one of the few companies that covers undetected pre existing conditions and wear and tear breakdowns, which are often excluded elsewhere. Their wide contractor base and plan flexibility make AHS a strong choice for homeowners who want comprehensive protection with minimal restrictions.

Pros :

  • Pre Existing Coverage.
  • Customizable Plans.
  • Large Contractor Network.

Where Services Are Available?

Available in 48 States. Coverage is not currently available in Alaska and Hawaii.

8

ARW Home – American Residential Warranty

  • Month to Month Plans.
  • Smart Tech Add Ons.
  • U.S. Based Support.

offer $100 OFF and 2 Months Free

Excellent fourhalf_star
4.2

Premium $54.99 - $64.99

Deductible $100.00 - $125.00

Total Coverage Benefits $10,000 Contractual Limit

Why We Chose ARW Home – American Residential Warranty?

American Residential Warranty offers flexibility without sacrificing coverage. Their no contract plans and optional bundles, like smart home or electronics protection, are ideal for tech savvy homeowners. With domestic customer support and easy plan management, they provide modern solutions for homeowners seeking simplicity and versatility.

Pros :

  • Month to Month Plans.
  • Smart Tech Add Ons.
  • U.S. Based Support.

Where Services Are Available?

Available in 50 States.

9

First American Home Warranty

  • Fast Appliance Repairs.
  • Easy Claims Process.
  • Realtor Recommended.

offer Flexible Payment Options

Good threehalf_star
3.6

Premium $54.99 - $64.99

Deductible $85.00

Total Coverage Benefits $10,000 Contractual Limit

Why We Chose First American Home Warranty?

First American is a longtime favorite among homebuyers and real estate professionals. Their appliance repair and replacement process is efficient and customer friendly. With competitive pricing and strong industry partnerships, they’re well suited for new homeowners or anyone needing straightforward, no fuss protection.

Pros :

  • Fast Appliance Repairs.
  • Easy Claims Process.
  • Realtor Recommended.

Where Services Are Available?

Available in 35 States. Coverage is not currently available in Alaska, Connecticut, Delaware, Hawaii, Illinois, Louisiana, Maine, Massachusetts, Minnesota, New Hampshire, New York, North Dakota, Rhode Island, Vermont and Wisconsin.

10

Cinch Home Services

  • 180 Day Repair Guarantee.
  • Appliance Credit Perks.
  • Digital Claim Tools.

offer Free Water Sensor and 2 Months Free

Good threehalf_star
3.4

Premium $54.99 - $64.99

Deductible $75.00 - $150.00

Total Coverage Benefits $10,000 Contractual Limit

Why We Chose Cinch Home Services?

Cinch Home Services brings reliability and ease to home protection. Their extended workmanship guarantee covers repairs for up to six months, while digital tools streamline every step of the process, from submitting a claim to tracking technician visits. It’s a perfect choice for busy homeowners who prioritize efficiency and long term coverage quality.

Pros :

  • 180 Day Repair Guarantee.
  • Appliance Credit Perks.
  • Digital Claim Tools.

Where Services Are Available?

Available in 48 States. Coverage is not currently available in Alaska and Hawaii.

Elite Home Warranty Named 2025’s Best Home Warranty Company Nationwide

HomeWarrantyCompanies.com, a trusted resource for comparing top-rated home warranty providers, publishes its annual rankings based on consumer satisfaction, service quality, and expert evaluation. After reviewing more than 25 leading providers, Elite Home Warranty was recognized as the #1 Home Warranty Company Nationwide for 2025. This honor reflects Elite’s proven commitment to delivering reliable coverage, outstanding service, and a customer-first experience. When it comes to protecting your home, Elite continues to set the standard.

Why Thousands of Homeowners Choose Elite Home Warranty?

Elite Home Warranty is not just another option, it’s a smarter choice backed by real results. Here’s what sets Elite apart:

  • Top Rated Customer Satisfaction: 4.9/5 stars across trusted platforms including BBB, Consumera, Google, and more.
  • Affordable Pricing: Competitive rates without hidden fees, inflated premiums, or misleading terms.
  • Fast Claims Processing: 90% of claims are reviewed and processed within 72 hours, with real time updates.
  • Best in Class Coverage You Can Count On: Industry leading coverage benefits and high payout limits, built to actually work when you need them.
  • Award Winning Support Team: U.S.-based customer service and claims concierge care available 7 days a week for fast, friendly assistance.

Is A Home Warranty Right for You?

Homeowners in New Jersey must carefully assess their needs. A home warranty covers repairs and replacements for essential systems and appliances. Each plan offers its mix of benefits and challenges. 

It is essential to know what is covered. A warranty can protect against sudden costs and ensure repairs are handled by professionals—the details of each plan matter. Home systems in New Jersey are often older. They are subject to harsh winter conditions, humidity in the summer, storms, and heavy snow.

Understanding Home Warranty Coverage

A home warranty is designed to cover unexpected failures. Coverage may include heating, cooling, plumbing, and electrical systems. It may also cover major appliances. In New Jersey, the weather can be unpredictable. This unpredictability can lead to breakdowns. 

A warranty plan acts as a safeguard. It is a way to control repair expenses. Plans are available with different levels of protection. They can be tailored to your home’s age and condition. The details matter. For example, some plans may not cover pre-existing conditions. 

Understanding what is included helps you avoid surprises. Transparent terms and conditions are essential; homeowners must read the fine print. A warranty plan should be a helpful tool. It can prevent costly repairs from draining your finances.

In addition, coverage details provide a roadmap for when things go wrong. Many providers offer optional add-ons for extra protection. You may choose to cover pools, spas, or even septic systems. The idea is to create a plan that fits your lifestyle. Each policy outlines its limits and deductibles. 

This clarity allows homeowners to budget better. It also ensures you have the necessary support when your home systems fail. Clear coverage means you know what to expect when a repair is needed. You can plan for the service fee and the cost of parts. This approach reduces uncertainty and financial risk.

Evaluating Your Home’s Needs and Potential Risks

Every home is unique. New Jersey homes range from century-old brownstones to modern condos. The age of your home affects how often repairs may be needed. If your home is older, you might face more frequent repairs. Consider the cost of routine maintenance.

Evaluate which systems are most vulnerable. For example, heating systems work hard during cold winters. They may fail unexpectedly. A warranty can help manage these risks. It ensures that if a system fails, repair costs are predictable. 

You can compare the potential repair bill with the monthly warranty cost. Think about the value of consistent service. Regular maintenance and quick repairs help preserve your home’s value.

In New Jersey, weather extremes can damage your home. Heavy snowfall and ice can damage roofs and gutters, and summer storms can flood basements. A warranty plan covers many of these eventualities. After evaluating your home’s age and condition, you can decide if the warranty is worth the investment. 

Detailed assessments can help you see the benefits. Talk to service professionals and get their advice. Compare your home’s history of repairs with the potential savings of a warranty. This step-by-step evaluation builds a strong case for why a warranty may be the right decision for your home.

Making an Informed Decision

Deciding on a home warranty requires research and comparison. Look at several providers. Compare their monthly fees, service fees, and coverage details. The decision should not be based solely on cost. You must consider the overall value. In New Jersey, where repair costs can be unpredictable, a warranty is a form of risk management. 

Consider the likelihood of system failures, reflect on the reliability of local repair services, and check customer reviews and ratings. Transparency in terms and conditions is crucial. A warranty plan should offer a balance of affordability and comprehensive protection.

Take time to understand each policy. Ask questions about what is covered. Inquire about claim procedures and repair turnaround times. Compare the cost of potential repairs with the price of the warranty plan. The idea is to protect your investment without incurring unexpected expenses. 

A detailed analysis of your home’s needs and a clear understanding of the warranty terms will help you make an informed decision. A well-chosen warranty provides not just financial relief but also peace of mind. It is a wise investment for homeowners facing the unpredictable weather and aging infrastructure typical of New Jersey.

Is A Home Warranty Worth the Cost In New Jersey?

Evaluating the cost of a home warranty is crucial. New Jersey homeowners face high repair costs, and a warranty can help manage these costs. It is essential to assess both the tangible and intangible benefits. The price must be measured against potential savings. The decision is not simple. It involves several factors and a detailed analysis.

Analyzing the Financial Impact of Home Repairs

Unexpected repairs can be costly. In New Jersey, harsh winters may lead to heating system failures, and the repair or replacement cost can quickly escalate. A warranty plan provides a fixed monthly fee that is easier to budget. 

Without a warranty, homeowners may face bills that run into hundreds or thousands of dollars. For instance, a broken boiler in winter may cost over $1,000 to fix. In contrast, a warranty plan might cost around $50 per month. This cost is predictable. 

It acts as a form of financial insurance, and the impact of these savings can be significant over time. Each repair is covered after a small service fee, typically between $70 and $85. This fee is far less than a complete repair bill.

Comparing Warranty Premiums and Out-of-Pocket Expenses

When comparing a warranty plan to paying out-of-pocket, it is essential to look at the details. Consider your home’s repair history. If repairs are frequent, the warranty may pay for itself. Premiums are set at a monthly rate. They provide coverage that would otherwise require large, unpredictable expenditures. 

Out-of-pocket expenses can be a heavy burden, especially during extreme weather events. A warranty plan offers a cap on your costs. By paying a consistent fee, you avoid sudden financial shocks. The plan’s structure allows for budgeting. 

You know the cost in advance. This predictability is valuable in managing household finances. Over a year, the warranty cost might be far less than several unexpected repairs.

Long-Term Benefits and Peace of Mind

A warranty plan is an investment in long-term home care. It covers immediate repairs as well as routine maintenance issues. Over time, the savings add up, and homeowners enjoy peace of mind knowing that repair costs are managed. 

The warranty plan offers convenience and reduces stress. It eliminates the need to find a repair service in an emergency. A straightforward claims process means faster repairs and less downtime. The long-term benefits include stability and predictability. 

This assurance is particularly valuable in New Jersey, where the harsh weather conditions demand a reliable protection system. When unexpected failures occur, the warranty acts as a financial buffer. The overall value of this peace of mind is immeasurable.

The decision to invest in a home warranty is a strategic one. It provides a safety net for both minor repairs and major system failures. The consistent cost and clear terms add to its appeal. When weighed against potential repair costs, a warranty can be a wise investment.

It protects your home and your budget. Homeowners can enjoy their living space rather than worry about repair bills. This long-term security is a key benefit of having a home warranty in New Jersey.

Who Oversees Home Warranty Companies in New Jersey?

Regulation of home warranty companies is a key factor in ensuring fairness. In New Jersey, strict oversight is in place. Several agencies ensure that providers follow state guidelines, protecting homeowners from unfair practices and subpar service. The regulatory framework is designed to maintain industry standards and transparency.

Regulatory Agencies and Licensing Requirements

Local and state agencies oversee home warranty companies and require them to obtain proper licenses. They also conduct regular audits to ensure compliance with established standards. 

Licensing requirements guarantee that only qualified providers operate. The agencies also monitor pricing practices, checking that fees and premiums are fair and transparent. Homeowners can be confident that regulated companies must follow strict guidelines. 

This oversight reduces the risk of fraud and ensures that claims are handled fairly and promptly. The regulatory framework is robust and protects both consumers and service providers. Clear rules and frequent inspections contribute to accountability.

Consumer Protection Laws and Their Impact

Consumer protection laws are a critical part of the oversight process. These laws require companies to be transparent about their coverage and fees. They protect homeowners from hidden charges. New Jersey consumers have the right to clear, understandable terms.

These laws allow for recourse if a company fails to meet its obligations. They empower homeowners to seek help if disputes arise. The legal framework is designed to enforce fairness. It ensures that companies deliver on their promises. 

Homeowners can rely on these laws to safeguard their interests. The impact is significant in building trust between providers and consumers.

The Role of Industry Associations and Self-Regulation

Industry associations also provide oversight. They set best practices and standards for members. Many companies participate in voluntary self-regulation, which helps maintain a high standard of service. 

Associations provide training and guidelines and mediate disputes between consumers and providers. This self-regulation complements state oversight. It encourages companies to be proactive about quality and service. 

The collaboration between regulators and industry associations benefits homeowners. It creates an environment of continuous improvement, and companies that adhere to these standards are often more reliable.

Ensuring Transparency and Accountability

Transparency is a cornerstone of effective regulation. Home warranty companies are required to disclose all costs. This includes monthly premiums, service fees, and any limitations in coverage. Regular audits and independent reviews keep companies accountable. 

In New Jersey, oversight ensures that companies follow through on their promises. Consumers have access to transparent, detailed information. This transparency builds trust. Accountability measures include penalties for non-compliance. 

These measures protect homeowners from deceptive practices. The oversight framework is comprehensive. It combines government regulation, consumer protection laws, and industry self-regulation to create a safe environment for homeowners.

Conclusion: Why a Home Warranty is Essential for New Jersey Homeowners

A home warranty is a wise investment for New Jersey homeowners. The region faces unpredictable weather and aging home systems. A warranty plan provides reliable protection. It manages repair costs and reduces financial stress. With transparent pricing and comprehensive coverage, homeowners gain peace of mind. 

The benefits include prompt service, consistent maintenance, and long-term savings. In New Jersey’s challenging environment, a home warranty is not just an option—it is essential. Make an informed choice to safeguard your home and secure your future.