ALLCOMPANIES BLOGS
color_picker

Best Home Warranty Companies in Maine: Comprehensive Guide for 2025

A home warranty in Maine is a valuable investment for homeowners looking to shield their properties from the high costs of unexpected repairs. In this comprehensive guide for 2025, we’ve reviewed the top 10 home warranty providers in Maine, focusing on their coverage, pricing, service fees, and standout features. These providers offer peace of mind year-round, from heating systems to essential appliances.

Top 10 Home Warranty Providers in Maine

The list below is of the best home warranty providers in Maine:

#1 RATED COMPANY

Elite Home Warranty
fourhalf_star 4.9/5

Elite Home Warranty
  • Premium
    -
    $44.99 - $59.99
  • Deductible
    -
    $0 & $70
  • Coverage Limit
    -
    $7,000
Call Now
Offers
$150 Off + 1 Month Free. 30 Day Free Trial!
phoneicon
48
States Covered
phoneicon
Accredited Business
BBB Rating
phoneicon
$15,000
Coverage Limits

Plans, Cost & Coverage

  • Coverage: Elite Home Warranty provides highly customizable plans that cover essential systems such as HVAC, plumbing, and electrical, as well as major appliances like refrigerators and dishwashers. Optional add-ons include roof leaks, pools, and septic systems.
  • Price: Plans start at $40 per month, with additional costs for optional add-ons.
  • Service Fee: Based on the selected plan, service fees range between $75 and $125.

Why We Picked Elite Home Warranty

Elite Home Warranty tops our list because it offers tailored coverage that meets the specific needs of Maine homeowners. Its focus on flexibility ensures that you only pay for what you need, making it a cost-effective choice.

In addition, Elite’s excellent customer service and fast claims processing provide peace of mind. Their reputation for transparency and reliability makes them the best option for protecting your home in Maine.

Excellent Services

Home Warranty of America
fourhalf_star 4.2/5

Home Warranty of America
  • Premium
    -
    $275 - $695
  • Deductible
    -
    $75 - $100
  • Coverage Limit
    -
    $400
Call Now
Offers
$150 Off + 1 Month Free*
phoneicon
50
States Covered
phoneicon
Not Accredited
BBB Rating
phoneicon
N/A
Coverage Limits

Plans, Cost & Coverage

  • Coverage: Offers two main plans—Premier and Premier Plus—covering essential home systems and appliances.
  • Price: Monthly plans range from $44 to $60, depending on coverage level.
  • Service Fee: Typically between $75 and $125 per service call.

Why We Picked Home Warranty of America

Home Warranty of America (HWA) stands out for its nationwide coverage and commitment to protecting homeowners against unexpected repair costs. Their plans cater to a wide range of needs, from basic appliance protection to comprehensive coverage, including HVAC systems and premium add-ons.

Comprehensive Coverage

The Home Service Club
fourhalf_star 4.1/5

The Home Service Club
  • Premium
    -
    $51.25 - $62.50
  • Deductible
    -
    $65,$95,$125
  • Coverage Limit
    -
    $800
Call Now
Offers
$75 Off + 1 Month Free
phoneicon
50
States Covered
phoneicon
Not Accredited
BBB Rating
phoneicon
N/A
Coverage Limits

Plans, Cost & Coverage

  • Coverage: The Home Service Club offers two plans: Standard Coverage and Comprehensive Coverage. These plans protect significant systems and appliances, with optional add-ons for roof leaks, sprinkler systems, and free-standing freezers.
  • Price: Plans start at $50 per month, with optional add-ons available.
  • Service Fee: Service fees range between $75 and $125.

Why We Picked The Home Service Club

The Home Service Club’s comprehensive plan options and inclusive coverage make it a top choice for Maine homeowners. Their plans are designed to cover a wide range of systems and appliances, ensuring peace of mind.

Their fast claims process and reliable service make them a standout provider. Homeowners in Maine looking for extensive protection and excellent service will find this company a strong contender.

Mike Holmes Protection
fourhalf_star 4.4/5

Mike Holmes Protection
  • Premium
    -
    $48-$88
  • Deductible
    -
    $58-$85
  • Coverage Limit
    -
    up to $25,000 per plan
Call Now
Offers
$100 Off + 1 Month Free
phoneicon
43
States Covered
phoneicon
Not Accredited
BBB Rating
phoneicon
up to $25,000 per plan
Coverage Limits

Plans, Cost & Coverage

  • Pricing: $48 – $88 per month, with flexible plan options to fit different homeowner needs.
  • Service Fees: Deductible ranges from $58 – $85 per service call, ensuring affordability and quality service.
  • Coverage Limit: Offers protection up to $3,000 – $6,000 per covered item, providing substantial financial relief for repairs and replacements.

Why We Picked Mike Holmes Protection

Mike Holmes Protection stands out for its commitment to quality and homeowner convenience. With virtual assistance, round-the-clock support, and unlimited coverage for home systems, homeowners can rest assured they’ll receive quick and reliable service when needed. The brand’s strong reputation and network of trusted professionals ensure high-quality workmanship for every repair.

Best Customer Support

Liberty Home Guard
fourhalf_star 4.7/5

Liberty Home Guard
  • Premium
    -
    $50 - $60
  • Deductible
    -
    $90
  • Coverage Limit
    -
    $2000
Call Now
Offers
$200 Off + 2 Months Free + Free Roof Leak Protection
phoneicon
50
States Covered
phoneicon
Not Accredited
BBB Rating
phoneicon
$2K/Item
Coverage Limits

Plans, Cost & Coverage

  • Coverage: Three plans—Appliance Guard, Systems Guard, and Total Home Guard—covering various home components.
  • Price: Plans start at $49.99 per month.
  • Service Fee: Approximately $90.

Why We Picked Liberty Home Guard

Liberty Home Guard is recognized for its commitment to customer service and providing a hassle-free claims process. Their wide range of coverage options ensures that homeowners can protect essential systems and appliances effectively. Liberty’s strong reputation for reliability and quality repairs makes it an excellent choice for those looking for a provider with proven expertise.

Nationwide Coverage

Regency Total Home Warranty
fourhalf_star 4.1/5

Regency Total Home Warranty
  • Premium
    -
    $39.99 - $58.90
  • Deductible
    -
    N/A
  • Coverage Limit
    -
    N/A
Call Now
Offers
$300 Off + 2 Months Free + FREE Limited Roof Leak Protection
phoneicon
50
States Covered
phoneicon
Not Accredited
BBB Rating
phoneicon
$5,000
Coverage Limits

Plans, Cost & Coverage

  • Coverage: Regency Total Home Warranty provides comprehensive plans covering systems like HVAC, plumbing, electrical, and major appliances. Optional add-ons include roof leak repairs and pool equipment.
  • Price: Plans start at $39.99 per month, making it affordable.
  • Service Fee: The service fee is $75 per claim.

Why We Picked Regency Total Home Warranty

Regency Total Home Warranty’s straightforward pricing and comprehensive plans make it a reliable choice for Maine homeowners. Their low service fees and robust coverage options provide excellent value.

The company’s commitment to quick and efficient claims processing further enhances its appeal. Regency’s focus on customer satisfaction makes them a strong option for homeowners seeking dependable coverage.

American Home Shield (AHS)
fourhalf_star 4.2/5

American Home Shield (AHS)
  • Premium
    -
    $29 - $79
  • Deductible
    -
    $100 & $125
  • Coverage Limit
    -
    $6000
phoneicon
48
States Covered
phoneicon
Accredited Business
BBB Rating
phoneicon
5,000
Coverage Limits

Plans, Cost & Coverage

  • Coverage: American Home Shield offers three plan options: ShieldSilver, ShieldGold, and ShieldPlatinum. These plans cover systems like HVAC, plumbing, and electrical, as well as major appliances such as dishwashers and refrigerators. The ShieldPlatinum plan provides the most extensive coverage, including roof leak repairs and higher coverage limits.
  • Price: Pricing starts at $39.99 per month, with additional costs for premium plans.
  • Service Fee: Service fees range from $75 to $125.

Why We Picked American Home Shield (AHS)

American Home Shield’s extensive coverage options and flexible pricing make it a top choice for Maine homeowners. Their ShieldPlatinum plan offers comprehensive protection, including roof repairs, which is particularly valuable in Maine’s climate.

Additionally, AHS has a long-standing reputation for reliability and quick claim processing. Their customizable plans and excellent service make them a trusted provider in the state.

America’s First Choice
fourhalf_star 4.6/5

America’s First Choice
  • Premium
    -
    $33 - $56
  • Deductible
    -
    $75 - $125
  • Coverage Limit
    -
    N/A
Call Now
Offers
$250 Off + Free Roof Leak Coverage
phoneicon
50
States Covered
phoneicon
Accredited Business
BBB Rating
phoneicon
N/A
Coverage Limits

Plans, Cost & Coverage

  • Coverage: AFC Home Club offers four plans: Silver, Systems, Gold, and Platinum. Coverage includes HVAC, plumbing, and electrical systems, as well as appliances such as refrigerators and dishwashers. Optional add-ons include septic systems and pool equipment.
  • Price: Plans start at $32 per month, making it an affordable choice.
  • Service Fee: Service fees range from $75 to $125.

Why We Picked America’s First Choice

AFC Home Club’s affordability and flexible service fee structure make it an appealing option for Maine homeowners. Their plans offer extensive coverage, and their optional add-ons cater to various needs.

AFC’s unique feature is its allowance for homeowners to choose their own contractors, ensuring high-quality repairs. This flexibility and customer-centric approach set it apart in the market.

First American Home Warranty
four_star 4/5

First American Home Warranty
  • Premium
    -
    $336 - $534+
  • Deductible
    -
    $85
  • Coverage Limit
    -
    $3,500
phoneicon
35
States Covered
phoneicon
Accredited Business
BBB Rating
phoneicon
N/A
Coverage Limits

Plans, Cost & Coverage

  • Coverage: First American Home Warranty offers two plan options: Basic and Premier. The Basic Plan covers essential appliances such as washers, dryers, and refrigerators, while the Premier Plan adds coverage for HVAC, plumbing, and electrical systems. Optional add-ons include pool equipment and additional refrigeration units.
  • Price: Plans start at $36 per month, with optional upgrades available.
  • Service Fee: The service fee is $85 per claim.

Why We Picked First American Home Warranty

First American Home Warranty’s affordability and straightforward plans make it an excellent option for homeowners in Maine. The Premier Plan offers comprehensive protection at a competitive price, making it ideal for those looking for robust coverage.

Their responsive customer service and quick claim resolution make them a reliable choice for Maine homeowners. Their combination of affordability and reliability secures their place on our list.

ARW Home – American Residential Warranty
fourhalf_star 4.3/5

ARW Home – American Residential Warranty
  • Premium
    -
    $45 - $84
  • Deductible
    -
    $125
  • Coverage Limit
    -
    N/A
Offers
2 Months FREE* on All Plans
phoneicon
50
States Covered
phoneicon
Not Accredited
BBB Rating
phoneicon
$1K
Coverage Limits

Plans, Cost & Coverage

  • Coverage: ARW Home Warranty specializes in protecting both home systems and electronics. Their Platinum Premier plan covers HVAC, plumbing, electrical systems, and appliances like refrigerators and washing machines. Add-ons for electronics such as laptops and TVs are available.
  • Price: Plans start at $34.99 per month.
  • Service Fee: The service fee is $100 per claim.

Why We Picked ARW Home – American Residential Warranty

ARW Home Warranty’s focus on electronics coverage sets it apart from competitors. Maine homeowners who rely on high-tech devices will appreciate their comprehensive plans.

In addition, ARW’s 24/7 customer service and flexible coverage options make it a convenient choice. Their dedication to modern solutions ensures Maine homeowners are well-protected.

Cinch Home Services
threehalf_star 3.9/5

Cinch Home Services
  • Premium
    -
    $27.99 ,$32.99,$39.99
  • Deductible
    -
    $100, $125, $150
  • Coverage Limit
    -
    $2,000
phoneicon
48
States Covered
phoneicon
Accredited Business
BBB Rating
phoneicon
N/A
Coverage Limits

Plans, Cost & Coverage

  • Coverage: Cinch Home Services offers three plans: the Appliances Plan, the Built-in Systems Plan, and the Complete Home Plan. The Complete Home Plan provides the most extensive coverage, combining systems and appliances, with added perks like a homeowners’ insurance deductible reimbursement.
  • Price: Plans start at $34.99 monthly, with premium plans averaging $55.
  • Service Fee: Service fees range from $100 to $150.

Why We Picked Cinch Home Services

Cinch Home Services’ unique features, such as the reimbursement of homeowners’ insurance deductibles, make it a standout option for Maine homeowners. Their Complete Home Plan provides broad coverage, ensuring protection against costly repairs.

Additionally, Cinch’s commitment to customer satisfaction and efficient claims processing makes them reliable. Their extensive plan options cater to a variety of homeowner needs in Maine.

America’s Preferred Home Warranty (APHW)
threehalf_star 3.9/5

America’s Preferred Home Warranty (APHW)
  • Premium
    -
    $39.58- $62.08
  • Deductible
    -
    $50, $75, $100, $125
  • Coverage Limit
    -
    $1,000
phoneicon
49
States Covered
phoneicon
Accredited Business
BBB Rating
phoneicon
N/A
Coverage Limits

Plans, Cost & Coverage

  • Coverage: APHW offers flexible plans that cover essential home systems like HVAC, plumbing, electrical, and major appliances. Optional add-ons include pools, sump pumps, and septic systems.
  • Price: Plans start at $39 per month, with customizable options available.
  • Service Fee: The service fee is $100 per claim.

Why We Picked America’s Preferred Home Warranty (APHW)

APHW’s unique feature of allowing homeowners to choose contractors makes it a standout option. This flexibility ensures Maine homeowners can work with trusted professionals.

Additionally, their straightforward pricing and customizable plans make APHW a reliable choice. Their focus on empowering homeowners sets them apart in the competitive home warranty market.

Is A Home Warranty Right For You In Maine?

As a homeowner in Maine, ensuring your property is protected against unexpected expenses can be a crucial decision. With the state’s unique climate, seasonal extremes, and the wear and tear of homeownership, a home warranty might be an appealing option to safeguard your investment. But is it the right choice for you? Let’s explore the factors Maine homeowners should consider when evaluating home warranty plans.

The Unique Needs Of Maine Homeowners

Maine’s climate is defined by harsh winters, humid summers, and coastal regions subject to salty air, which can accelerate the deterioration of home systems and appliances. For homeowners, this means:

A home warranty tailored to these regional factors could offer peace of mind and financial protection.

Benefits Of A Home Warranty in Maine

  1. Coverage for Frequent Repairs: Maine’s climate and older housing stock often lead to heating, plumbing, and electrical system breakdowns. A home warranty ensures that repair costs don’t spiral out of control.
  2. Budget-Friendly Protection: Instead of facing unexpected repair or replacement costs, a home warranty allows you to pay a predictable monthly or annual premium. This can help with budgeting, especially for first-time homeowners.
  3. Seasonal Maintenance Support: Many warranty plans offer additional services, such as HVAC maintenance, which can keep systems running smoothly year-round.
  4. Peace of Mind: Whether it’s a mid-winter boiler failure or a leaky roof during a spring thaw, a home warranty can save you from the stress of finding a reliable contractor and covering hefty bills.

Things To Consider Before Choosing A Home Warranty

  1. Existing Coverage: Determine what your homeowner’s insurance already covers and where the gaps lie. A home warranty complements insurance by covering wear-and-tear failures but won’t duplicate coverage for disasters or accidents.
  2. Age of Your Home and Systems: If your appliances or systems are relatively new, they might still be under the manufacturer’s warranty. Older systems, however, are often the best candidates for home warranty coverage.
  3. Cost vs. Benefit: Evaluate the annual premium and service call fees against your systems’ potential repair or replacement costs. In Maine, heating system repairs alone can easily exceed $500, while replacing a furnace might cost $3,000 or more.
  4. Exclusions and Limits: Not all home warranties are created equal. Some may not cover pre-existing issues, corrosion due to salty air, or repairs caused by neglect. Always read the fine print carefully.
  5. Reputation of Providers: Choose a provider with a strong track record of customer service and timely repairs. Check reviews, particularly from other Maine residents, to gauge how the provider handles regional challenges.

Common Scenarios Where Maine Homeowners Benefit

  1. Unexpected Heating Failures: Your furnace suddenly breaks down in the middle of a snowstorm. A home warranty can arrange a fast repair without you footing the full cost.
  2. Plumbing Freezes and Bursts: Maine’s freezing temperatures can cause pipes to burst, leading to water damage and repair costs. Many warranties cover plumbing system repairs.
  3. Storm-Related Appliance Damage: Power surges or heavy snow accumulation can cause appliances to malfunction. A home warranty can help cover repairs or replacements.

Tips for Maximizing the Value Of A Home Warranty

  1. Perform Regular Maintenance: Providers may deny claims if systems haven’t been appropriately maintained. Keeping up with routine tasks ensures that your systems stay in good condition.
  2. Bundle with Insurance Discounts: Some home warranty providers offer discounts if you bundle them with homeowners insurance. Explore these options to reduce costs.
  3. Track Repairs: Maintain records of past repairs and appliance purchases. This can help you negotiate better coverage or claim resolution.
  4. Opt for Customizable Plans: Maine homeowners often need specific heating systems, plumbing, and roofing coverage. Choose plans that allow add-ons for these critical systems.

Is a Home Warranty Worth the Cost in Maine?

Deciding whether a home warranty is worth the investment can depend on several factors unique to Maine, including the state’s climate, home types, and homeowner needs. Let’s break down the essential considerations to help you make an informed decision.

How Maine’s Climate Affects Home Appliances & Systems

Maine’s harsh winters and humid summers can damage home systems like HVAC units, boilers, and plumbing. A home warranty can provide peace of mind when weather-induced wear and tear leads to breakdowns, ensuring your repairs or replacements are covered without incurring substantial out-of-pocket expenses.

The Impact of Maine’s Older Homes On Maintenance Costs

Maine is known for its historic homes, many of which have aging systems and appliances. If you own or plan to purchase an older property, the likelihood of system failures increases significantly. A home warranty can act as a financial buffer, helping you manage unexpected repair costs that are standard in older homes.

Home Warranty Costs vs. Emergency Repair Expenses in Maine

The average cost of a home warranty ranges between $300 and $600 annually, with service fees for claims typically around $75 to $125 per visit. Compare this with the potential cost of repairing or replacing a furnace during Maine’s winter, ranging from $300 for minor repairs to $6,000 for a complete replacement. For many homeowners, the numbers often justify the warranty.

How First-Time Homebuyers In Maine Can Benefit from a Home Warranty

First-time homebuyers often lack the financial safety net or technical expertise to handle unexpected home repairs. A home warranty can be affordable and protect your investment, avoiding budget strain, especially in the first year of homeownership when cash flow might be tight.

Seasonal Demands On Maine Homes & Their Systems

Maine’s seasonal demands—like heavy snow affecting roofs and ice buildup straining plumbing—can create sudden, costly emergencies. A home warranty provides year-round coverage, ensuring seasonal issues don’t become financial headaches.

Customizing Home Warranties For Maine-Specific Needs

Many home warranty providers offer plans tailored to specific needs. In Maine, homeowners may benefit from policies prioritizing coverage for heating systems, plumbing, and even sump pumps, essential for homes prone to basement flooding during spring melts.

What To Look for When Choosing A Home Warranty Provider In Maine

When selecting a home warranty, ensure the provider offers:

#1 RATED COMPANY

$150 Off + First Month Free

Don't let broken appliance break the bank

hwc-logo

4.9 /5

(888) 894-6151

Who Oversees Home Warranty Companies In Maine?

Home warranty companies in Maine operate under specific regulations designed to protect homeowners and ensure fair practices. While these companies are not regulated as strictly as insurance providers, various agencies and regulatory frameworks provide oversight to maintain accountability and transparency. Understanding who oversees home warranty companies in Maine can help you make informed decisions and address any concerns effectively.

The Role Of The Maine Bureau Of Insurance

In Maine, the primary agency responsible for oversight of warranty-related services is the Maine Bureau of Insurance. While home warranty companies are not classified as traditional insurance providers, the Bureau may step in if a company’s practices overlap with insurance-like activities.

The Bureau ensures compliance with state laws, investigates complaints, and provides consumers with resources to address disputes. Although home warranties are considered service contracts rather than insurance policies, the Bureau’s involvement is essential in protecting homeowners against deceptive practices.

The Service Contract Act And State-Level Oversight

Home warranty companies are often regulated under the Maine Service Contract Act. This legislation sets guidelines for service contract providers, including home warranty companies, regarding:

The Service Contract Act aims to create a framework that holds providers accountable while offering transparency to homeowners.

Licensing And Registration Requirements

Maine requires home warranty companies to register and obtain licenses to operate within the state. Licensing ensures that companies meet minimum standards for financial solvency and ethical practices. The licensing process typically involves:

These requirements prevent fraudulent companies from entering the market and ensure that legitimate providers can meet their contractual obligations.

National Organizations And Their Influence

While Maine enforces its regulations, national organizations such as the National Association of Insurance Commissioners (NAIC) provide additional oversight and guidance. The NAIC works to harmonize rules across states and offers a framework for consumer protection. Although the NAIC does not directly govern home warranties, their guidelines often influence state-level practices, including in Maine.

Additionally, some Maine-based homeowners rely on reviews and ratings from third-party organizations like the Better Business Bureau (BBB) or industry-specific accreditation boards to evaluate the trustworthiness of home warranty providers.

Consumer Protection Resources In Maine

Maine homeowners who encounter issues with a home warranty company can turn to several resources for assistance:

  1. Maine Bureau of Consumer Credit Protection: Offers guidance on resolving disputes related to service contracts.
  2. Maine Attorney General’s Office: Handles complaints about home warranty companies’ deceptive or unfair trade practices.
  3. Small Claims Court: For unresolved disputes, homeowners may file a claim in Maine’s small claims court to recover losses.

These resources allow homeowners to hold companies accountable and seek resolution when contracts are not honored.

How Oversight Benefits Homeowners In Maine

The regulatory framework in Maine ensures that home warranty companies operate with integrity and transparency. Key benefits include:

By maintaining a robust oversight system, Maine aims to balance the interests of both consumers and home warranty providers, fostering trust and reliability in the industry.

Conclusion: Why A Home Warranty is Essential for Maine

Maine’s harsh winters can significantly stress heating systems, plumbing, and appliances, making a home warranty a valuable investment. It ensures homeowners are financially prepared for breakdowns caused by freezing temperatures or heavy usage.

A home warranty provides consistent protection in a state where seasonal changes impact home systems. This helps homeowners avoid unexpected repair bills and ensures their homes stay comfortable year-round.